Honest Mistake In Not Documenting Private Company Loans

Share on facebook
Facebook
Share on twitter
Twitter
Share on linkedin
LinkedIn

A taxpayer has been, in most part, successful before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) in relation to a matter concerning loans from a private company.

These loans were made to him, over various years, as a shareholder and director of the private company.

The ATO had treated the loans, which were made in the 2005, 2006 and 2007 income years, as assessable dividends.
The AAT sided with the ATO in relation to the 2005 loans.

However, the AAT decided differently in respect of the 2006 and 2007 loans. It found that a discretion under the tax law should be exercised to disregard the deemed dividends because it found that there was an “honest mistake” in failing to properly document the loans.
NOTE: The Tax Commissioner has the ability to disregard a deemed dividend, or allow it to be franked, if certain conditions are met.

Generally, a taxpayer must apply to the Commissioner to ask for the discretion to be exercised, and must be able to demonstrate that the failure to meet the requirements of the law was due to an honest mistake or an inadvertent omission.
In making his decision, the Commissioner must have regard to various factors specified in the law.

Please contact our office if you have any questions.

  • Get in touch

OUR DIRECTORS

Chris Mandzufas

Chris Mandzufas

Chris has a diverse range of skills and experience as a result of providing accounting, taxation, advisory board and management consulting services to owners and directors of fast growing businesses.

Chris Smith

Chris Smith

Chris Smith has been a member of the Chartered Accountants Australia & New Zealand since 2006, a member of the Tax Institute of Australia since 2013, and a registered Tax Agent since 2018.

Tony Monisse

Tony Monisse

Tony’s key focus is the integration of strategy and financial management. To this end he has developed tools and process that facilitate this integration, including business modelling, target setting and rolling cash flow forecasts.

Maximise your Business Potential

Whether it’s business growth, improved profitability and cashflow or streamlining operations to improve work/life balance, we can help you achieve your business goals. Gain clarity on which strategies will accelerate the success of your business

Our Impact

icon

INCREASE IN PROFIT AND CASHFLOW

Icon

IMPROVED ALIGNMENT AMONG LEADERSHIP

icon

IMPROVED CLARITY IN FINANCIALS AND FINANCIAL WELL BEING

Icon

IMPROVED STRATEGIC FOCUS

Icon

GREATER ACCOUNTABILITY AMONG LEADERSHIP

icon

IMPROVED MULTIPLE FOR BUSINESS VALUATION

Download the Info Pack